154) Lou Christie – “Lightnin’ Strikes”

“Lightnin’ Strikes” is a difficult record to get a handle on. On one hand, it rivals “Leader of the Pack” for sheer melodrama,  courtesy of the song’s shifting multi-part verses, the kitchen-sink production (by ex-Four Seasons arranger Charles Calello) and Lou Christie’s octave-scaling vocals. On the other hand, there’s the lyrics. “Lightnin’ Strikes” is the pop epitome of the double standard, where Christie can plead for “a girl he can trust to the very end” while at in the same breath try to justify his own infidelity through condescension (“you’re old enough to know the makings of a man”) and bathos (“believe it or not, you’re in my heart all the time”). Even given the era’s gender norms and rock’s pervasive misogyny, the shamelessness of a line like “for the time being, baby, live by my rules” is really something else. (Likewise, he’s careful to imply he’ll marry her without ever quite committing to it.)

In fact, the lines Christie smarmily croons in “Lightnin’ Strikes” are so brazen that you have to wonder if they’re meant to be ironic. The song was co-written by Christie with longtime collaborator Twyla Herbert, a self-described mystic and bohemian more than two decades his senior – not a woman all that concerned with conforming to social norms. Further, “Lightnin’ Strikes” seems geared to emphasize an association between sexism and violence. The prechorus, where Christie’s strained voice shouts “I can’t stop myself!” while female backing singers cry “Stop! Stop!,” is notoriously ambiguous. Is our narrator an unrepentant Casanova or something far more sinister?

“Lightnin’ Strikes” even borrows the format of a horror story. Its verses are a burlesque of innocence, thick with tinkling piano, church bells and an idyllic “chapel in the pines.” Even so, there are hints that things aren’t quite as they appear. Christie’s transparent phoniness implies there’s something in his true nature that needs concealing. The crashing piano chords opening each verse suggest distant cracks of thunder, warning of a coming storm. Even the backing vocals are so exaggerated in their sweetness that they verge on grotesque.

Of course, as in any horror story, this perfect world exists only to be shattered. When Christie spots “lips begging to be kissed,” his voice mutates into a shrill keen, completely unrecognizable from the charmer he posed as just seconds earlier. The switch from his teen idol croon to the manic, otherworldly falsetto signifies that he has transformed into some unknown thing incapable of being controlled. His choice of words – “lightning striking me again!” – links him with the violence of a sudden, unpredictable burst of energy that burns hot and leaves destruction in its wake. It also evokes the electrical flash that brought Frankenstein’s monster to life.

Nevertheless, Christie, Herbert and Calello never entirely tip their hand as to the song’s true meaning. Perhaps the record is exactly what it appears to be, no irony or grotesquerie intended. This uncertainty complements the song’s constantly shifting structure: you never can get too comfortable with “Lightnin’ Strikes,” which is precisely what makes it so compelling. There are plenty of terrible records with well-meaning messages. The ambiguous intent of this one only adds to its allure. 8

Hit #1 on February 19, 1966; total of 1 week at #1
154 of 1016 #1’s reviewed; 15.15% through the Hot 100


Filed under 08, 1966

2 responses to “154) Lou Christie – “Lightnin’ Strikes”

  1. Pinstripe Hourglass

    The great Klaus Nomi (who could have come out of a Hammer Horror himself) covered this on his first album: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gma5IUNMTn0
    The song was practically made for him, really. His theatrical, creepy persona plus the inherent dissonance of a flamboyant homosexual singing an ostensibly straight love song make the the ambiguity all the more potent. Personally, I can’t decide if I prefer the sinister hidden or right up front.

  2. I’ve always heard the B sections – ‘Every Boy…’, ‘When I settle down…’, ‘There’s a chapel in the pines..’ – as comic, mock heroic (not quite the same thing as irony I would have thought). The space that opens up in the song at those points is meant for an audience to fill with laughter (that’s certainly what happens when I’ve seen the song covered). Some Mag Fields songs work in the same way (e.g., A Pretty Girl is Like…)

    Anyhow, it’s a dervish of a record, every few bars striking out in some new direction, and so doesn’t sound quite like anything else, except perhaps the Shangs’s Remember (Walking in the Sand), although I much prefer that records. Come to think of it, R(WItS) is a record that’s got a spooky Chabrol/Horror vibe to it, I’m not buying that at all with repesct to Lightning Strikes!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s