162) The Beatles – “Paperback Writer”

The “Paperback Writer” single is one of the odd cases where the flipside of a record proves more influential than the hit. “Rain,” the B-side in question, is credited as a watershed in The Beatles’ transformation into studio experimentalists, though it’s less notable as a song than as a Whitman’s Sampler of tape effects: sped-up lead vocals, slowed-down rhythm track, a fade-out followed by a fade-in and, most strikingly, John Lennon’s voice run backwards in the coda.  In comparison, “Paperback Writer” could easily be overlooked as one more of the band’s riff-driven rockers – “son of ‘Day Tripper,'” as Lennon himself later called it.* But while “Paperback Writer” may have been more immediate and commercial than its flip, it too foreshadows Revolver’s sonic exploration and eclecticism. The song dispenses with the band’s trademark sticky choruses and distinctive chord progressions, instead locking on to a single G7 chord for nearly the entire verse. (Paul McCartney cites Little Richard as inspiration, but it also brings to mind the drone of raga-influenced Revolver tracks “Love You To” and “Tomorrow Never Knows.”) McCartney’s infatuation with Stax and Motown (cf. “Got to Get You Into My Life”**) inspired the boosted sound of his ever-melodic bass guitar; it would remain essentially a co-lead instrument from Revolver on. The distorted guitar riff, pushier and thornier than “Day Tripper”’s groove, points toward psychedelic rock, as does the trippy vocal echo on the harmonies at the end of the verse: a prêt–à–porter take on “Rain”’s avant-gardisms.

The lyrics of “Paperback Writer” also hint at the expanded subject matter The Beatles were beginning to explore. The name-checking of Edward Lear in the verse and “Frère Jacques” in the backing harmonies preview “Yellow Submarine” and Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band’s fixation with willful nonsense and childlike whimsy. More directly, the song itself is an early example of the type of character vignette McCartney would develop with “Eleanor Rigby” and “For No One,” but with those songs’ pathos swapped for a satirical take on the drive for fame.  The narrator has ambition and self-confidence to spare, assuring his anonymous contact that his thousand-plus-page behemoth will be an instant bestseller and breathlessly pleading for a break.  Whether he’s got the talent is another question. For all his attempts to dress his manuscript up in the trappings of a salable pulp paperback (“it’s a dirty story of a dirty man”), it’s clear that it’s in fact a dense autobiographical roman à clef, penned by a writer whose overearnest proposals to change his novel aren’t exactly proof of artistic integrity. (That he claims it’s based on a novel by Edward Lear, who never actually wrote a novel, seems in keeping with both his eagerness to say the right things and his all-around cluelessness.) While such a depiction of a struggling wannabe could seem mean-spirited coming from a band at the pinnacle of both creativity and fame, the song treats the aspiring novelist with a measure of affection and good humor. He may be naïve but he’s also sincere, and it’s hard not to root for his unlikely novel to be accepted. (Note that the only time the song changes chords is on the phrase “paperback writer,” as if acknowledging that’s the only way out of his rut.) Perhaps The Beatles even recognized something familiar in the story: the tale of a creative young man trying to pack a thousand pages’ worth of ideas and personal expression into a typically disposable, commercial piece of pop culture. 8

*From David Sheff’s All We Are Saying: The Last Major Interview with John Lennon and Yoko Ono. Of course, it’s worth remembering that Lennon was the primary author of “Day Tripper” while McCartney wrote “Paperback Writer,” and that McCartney won the A-side of both singles.

**In which, incidentally, McCartney reprises the “Paperback Writer” guitar riff.

Hit #1 on June 25, 1966 for 2 weeks; repeaked on July 9, 1966 for 1 week; total of 3 weeks at #1
162 of 1018 #1’s reviewed; 15.91% through the Hot 100



Filed under 08, 1966

8 responses to “162) The Beatles – “Paperback Writer”

  1. Sure, McCartney’s narrator refers to “a man named Lear,” but there’s no textual evidence to support the idea that Edward is the Lear in question, is there? (A great writeup otherwise.)

  2. I confess I cheated a bit there! Macca’s said he got the name off an Edward Lear book of John’s, and then there’s the theory that the song’s meant to be a jibe at Lennon, who’d already published two books of Lear-inspired nonsense by this point. But yes, that’s extratextual and totally unofficial, which is why it got buried in a parenthetical as a half-baked tangent.

  3. col1234

    it’s the best line of the song, though: the shamelessness of a hack proposing a novel based on another novel (I suppose the equivalent today would be someone trying to sell a “Twilight” knockoff), with also the subtext of McCartney taking a slight dig at Lennon beneath it, Because while McCartney in 1966 was the real avant-garde London hipster, while Lennon was ensconced in his mansion in the suburbs, the public image of the two—Lennon, artist; Macca, cute craftsman–was the reverse (and still remains so).

    not sure how I feel about this song: it’s one of the flashiest and more shallow Beatles singles of the period. It sounds great, and there’s a great energy to it, but it pales compared to “We Can Work It Out” or the “Strawberry Fields/ Penny Lane” single soon to come.

  4. I probably would have stuck “Paperback Writer” in my Beatles top 10 before writing this. Close listening makes it much more obvious how transitional it really is. I do love the lyrics, though, and it’s kind of a relief to hear The Beatles do flashy and shallow sometimes! Soon enough they’ll be Serious Artists, where even their fun songs start being heavily thought through and worked over.

  5. Anonymous

    On another note, that’s an amazingly good looking video clip for the 60s. Would that 70s/80s music videos looked so good.

  6. Freddy Freeloader

    I thought both PW/Rain and Day Tripper/ WCWIO were technically released as double-A sides. Wikipedia says DT/W.. was but not the other.

  7. I believe “Rain” was only marketed as a B-side – even for The Beatles, that would have been an extreme A-side! You are right about “Day Tripper” / “We Can Work It Out,” but I didn’t cover “Day Tripper” because it peaked at #5. The Hot 100 factors in radio airplay as well as sales, so both sides of a double A-sided single don’t necessarily chart in the same position. Coincidentally, the next post on this blog will cover a number-one that was featured on a double A-sided single, but its companion didn’t even make the Top 40.

  8. Anonymous

    Do you happen to know where the “(Paul McCartney cites Little Richard as inspiration,” reference is from? Was it an article or video? Was it from McCartney 321?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s