4) Tommy Edwards – “It’s All in the Game”

Tommy Edwards had a #18 hit with a pre-rock version of “It’s All in the Game” seven years before this rerecording topped the charts.  The 1958 version makes a few concessions to rock ‘n’ roll, adding a thudding drumbeat and “duh doo, duh doo” backing vocals.  Still, these are minor enhancements, far from The Elegants‘ embrace of rock as a method of updating an old sound.  Edwards acts as omniscient narrator, advising a young lady that while her lover may be casually (or callously) inconsiderate, she should be patient and a wedding ring would be her reward.  It’s not that Edwards’s voice is without emotion, exactly, but it’s so smooth as to lack any texture to allow the listener a way in.  It doesn’t help that the song was originally an instrumental called “Melody in A Major,” with the tacked-on lyrics at times scanning awkwardly (“ALL in the WON-der-FUL GAME”) or making no sense (“caress your waiting fingertips”).  Given the proliferation of covers this song produced by artists I admire (Van Morrison, Jackie DeShannon, The Four Tops), I want to think that one more listen will reveal the hidden delights hiding in “It’s All in the Game.” But then I listen again, and it doesn’t. 4

Liner Notes

  • I don’t think I can write about this song and avoid mentioning its music trivia status as the only #1 pop single to be (co)written by a U.S. vice president. The aforementioned “Melody in A Major” was composed in 1911 by Charles Dawes, who served under Calvin Coolidge from 1925 to 1929.  Which makes me wonder: are there any other charting pop songs (co)written by U.S. vice presidents? Heck, I’ll even expand it to U.S. presidents, speakers of the house, secretaries of state and justices on the Supreme Court.

Hit #1 on September 29, 1958; total of 6 weeks at #1
4 of 963 #1’s reviewed; 0.42% through the Hot 100



Filed under 04, 1958

4 responses to “4) Tommy Edwards – “It’s All in the Game”

  1. GeorgeL

    Aw come on. I love this song. It is so pretty & romantic. The 4 Tops version is pretty cool too. The first version I ever heard was Jackie DeShannon’s when she sang it on a teen dance show. I used to have the Van Morrison album where he sang it but haven’t heard it in years.

  2. “Caress your waiting fingertips” comes across as pretty erotic to me! Apart from the “S”s (a recording problem?) this is a great vocal performance imho… he carries a boring song, along with the electric guitar skirting around with the doo-op singers (most apparent in the final ten seconds)… 6.

  3. ES

    I think Nelson Rockefeller might have written “Honky Tonk Woman,” but i could be wrong about that.

  4. Marc Rettus

    Might as well say it was the first number one by an African American, too.

    Might as well say it was the first number one by someone named after a US president, intention or not. (Thomas Jefferson Edwards.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s